Newcastle United had been thrashed 4-0 on the Etihad Stadium as Manchester Metropolis‘s £59m winter signing Omar Marmoush bagged a first-half hat-trick.
Whereas Metropolis have been out of kinds this time period, they showcased a few of their previous aptitude and guile in opposition to Eddie Howe‘s outfit, who stoop to seventh within the Premier League standings, nursing a 3rd defeat in 4 top-flight matches.
The error-strewn show has served as a actuality verify of kinds. Howe has loads of work to do so as to restore United’s Champions League pedigree and put together for a Carabao Cup ultimate in opposition to Liverpool.
One factor that Howe might want to do at Wembley – and over the approaching months within the league – is get the group choice proper. He undoubtedly did not in opposition to Pep Guardiola‘s facet.
Howe will get it incorrect
Howe is an professional tactician, crafting a system that has bore dividends for Newcastle over the previous few seasons. Nevertheless, Pep appears to have his quantity and proved this with a complete win over the Magpies.
One of the peculiar selections was to maintain Kieran Trippier within the beginning 11 in lieu of Tino Livramento, who has his place to the 34-year-old after his clear sheet show in opposition to Arsenal within the Carabao Cup.
He misplaced each of his duels, as per Sofascore, and didn’t include a Man Metropolis facet that performed with gusto and enthusiasm and, most significantly, confidence. The shift when Livramento got here on on the interval wasn’t important, however the youthful man’s vitality and crispness within the sort out – successful each of his duels – did make a giant distinction in decreasing the hosts’ menace.
Newcastle did not hit their rhythm, as an alternative taking part in to Metropolis’s strengths and persevering with a depressing and abiding run in opposition to them: Newcastle have solely overwhelmed Metropolis as soon as within the Premier League for the reason that 2005/06 season.
Trippier’s right-back berth did not assist issues, however his reverse quantity at left-back, Lewis Corridor, ought to be extremely pissed off along with his meek displaying.
Howe should boldly drop Lewis Corridor
Trippier was fairly dangerous, and it was a questionable determination to put him within the beginning line-up with Livramento’s athleticism extra suited to the rigorous take a look at. Nevertheless, Corridor ought to have accomplished much better in opposition to Man Metropolis.
The 20-year-old was described as “the most effective left-back within the nation” by correspondent Dominic Scurr earlier within the marketing campaign however confirmed little signal of authority as he was steamrolled by the energetic Savinho.
As is the character of social media, Corridor can be rebuked for his efficiency in Manchester, and whereas he was certainly poor, there’s little query that he is some of the proficient younger gamers within the Premier League.
Nevertheless, he’ll be dismayed that his efforts in opposition to the four-in-a-row champions did not mirror that.
The Northern Echo’s Scott Wilson was notably scalding in his post-match feedback, noting that the deservedly-hooked Trippier was culpable for a ‘dreadful error’ within the build-up to Marmoush’s opening strike, however that Corridor wasn’t significantly better.
In truth, Corridor wasn’t any higher. Additionally branded with a 3/10 match score, Wilson stated this of Corridor’s efficiency: ‘His defensive limitations had been repeatedly uncovered by Savinho – particularly poor for Metropolis’s third aim.’
It wasn’t all doom and gloom. Metropolis’s relentless attacking referred to as the full-back into making seven tackles, additionally successful eight of his 11 duels on the afternoon, as per Sofascore. Nevertheless, such metrics do not paint the total image, with reporter Adam Clery making a candid assertion on the woeful effort.
The FourFourTwo journalist stated: “Lewis Corridor’s been excellent this season, however he’s at present placing in one of many single worst defensive performances I’ve seen in a very long time. Backing off all the best way into his personal field after which nonetheless getting ran previous. He appears to be like like he’s 36.”
BBC Sport pundit Chris Sutton additionally chipped in on the criticism, singling Corridor out and commenting that he seemed “completely scared of Savinho,” happening to say that the English defender could not “cope” with the depth and fleet-footedness of his adversary.
Newcastle – Upcoming Fixtures |
||
---|---|---|
Date |
Competitors |
Opponent |
23/02/25 |
Premier League |
Nott’m Forest (H) |
26/02/25 |
Premier League |
Liverpool (A) |
02/03/25 |
FA Cup |
Brighton (H) |
10/03/25 |
Premier League |
West Ham (A) |
16/03/25 |
Carabao Cup |
Liverpool (N) |
Newcastle will brush themselves off after this setback – particularly with an important run of video games arising – however the likes of Corridor will use this as a brutal actuality verify, one which may immediate Howe to make a daring intervention and place possibly Dan Burn and even Matt Targett at left-back for subsequent weekend’s essential contest in opposition to third-place Nottingham Forest at St. James’ Park.
Forest aren’t any joke however the enterprise interval of the marketing campaign will hit United like a freight prepare, with a visit to Anfield coming simply three days after the conflict in opposition to Nuno Espirito Santo’s males.
Newcastle truly received 49% of the duels on the day, additionally popping out with a 62% sort out success fee in comparison with Man Metropolis’s 50% win fee.
The distinction is that the Sky Blues had been incisive and pounced on the mistake-filled and unconvincing particular person efforts of the Magpies.
The consensus at full-time was that Newcastle had been uncharacteristically passive, missing their common chew and synergy – particularly in the midst of the park.
The likes of Corridor can be dejected after such a poor outing, however there’s nonetheless every little thing to play for over on Tyneside, and Newcastle have proved time and time once more their powers of restoration and talent to climate the storm and are available out on prime.
It is clear that Livramento ought to take his berth again from the ageing Trippier on the precise, and whereas Corridor’s obtained a giant future forward of him and has been an integral cog within the Howe machine this yr, he hasn’t been named in its place since September, and a tweak could also be worthwhile within the brief time period.

Associated
His worth has risen by £87m: Newcastle struck gold on “world-class” star
Eddie Howe has turned this Newcastle expertise into one of many world’s greatest.