Managers, Umpires, and Executives Get Their Corridor of Fame Shot By way of 2024 Modern Baseball Poll


Joe West
Orlando Ramirez-USA TODAY Sports activities

One of many extra optimistic outcomes of the Corridor of Fame’s newest spherical of restructuring its Period Committees in 2022 was the creation of a poll restricted to managers, umpires, and executives, eradicating them from immediately competing with gamers for votes and positioning them inside a triennial election cycle. On Thursday, the Corridor unveiled its slate of eight candidates for the 2024 Modern Baseball Period Committee Managers/Executives/Umpires poll, devoted to candidates in these classes who made their best influence from 1980 to the current. The candidates might be voted upon on the Winter Conferences in Nashville, Tennessee on December 3, with the outcomes introduced stay at 7:30 p.m. ET on MLB Community’s MLB Tonight.

The eight-member poll consists of 4 managers, two executives, and two umpires. 5 of the eight are first-time candidates, and 7 of the eight are nonetheless alive:

2024 Modern Baseball Period Committee Managers/Executives/Umpires poll

Candidate Class Most Latest Poll Look
Cito Gaston Supervisor None (1st time)
Davey Johnson Supervisor 2019 At the moment’s Sport Period Committee
Jim Leyland Supervisor None (1st time)
Lou Piniella Supervisor 2019 At the moment’s Sport Period Committee
Ed Montague Umpire None (1st time)
Joe West Umpire None (1st time)
Hank Peters* Government None (1st time)
Invoice White Government 2010 Veterans Committee, Executives/Pioneers

* = deceased

Whereas these candidates aren’t totally with out controversy — West specifically — weighty subjects akin to segregation and performance-enhancing medication gained’t dominate the discussions, which comes as a welcome aid. To be eligible for inclusion, managers and umpires must have compiled 10 or extra main league seasons and been retired for no less than 5 years, although candidates 65 years or older are eligible six months following retirement. Executives must have been retired for no less than 5 years, although energetic executives 70 years or older are eligible “whatever the place they maintain in a corporation and no matter whether or not their physique of labor has been accomplished,” in response to the Corridor’s guidelines.

The poll was assembled by a Historic Overview Committee, comprised of 10 veteran BBWAA members: Bob Elliott (Canadian Baseball Community); Jim Henneman (previously Baltimore Solar); Steve Hirdt (Stats Carry out); David O’Brien (The Athletic); Jack O’Connell (BBWAA secretary/treasurer); Jim Reeves (previously Fort Price Star-Telegram); Tracy Ringolsby (; Glenn Schwarz (previously San Francisco Chronicle); Susan Slusser (San Francisco Chronicle); and Mark Whicker (Los Angeles Information Group).

A separate committee of 16 individuals, appointed by the Corridor of Fame board of administrators and comprised of Corridor of Famers, executives, and writers/historians, will focus on and vote on the candidates; they”ll be introduced nearer to election time. Every voter can embrace as much as three candidates on his or her poll (down from 4 within the earlier Period Committee format, which included 10 candidates). Election to the Corridor requires 75%, that means votes from 12 of the 16 committee members.

Of the three repeat candidates, Piniella missed election by a single vote on the 2019 At the moment’s Sport poll, the one through which Lee Smith was elected unanimously and Harold Baines acquired 75%; two years earlier, Piniella acquired 43.8%. Johnson was among the many seven candidates who acquired “5 or fewer” votes on the 2019 poll, and likewise for the ’17 one, although it’s affordable to surmise he was at or close to the pinnacle of the pack among the many also-rans, provided that he retains getting picked for ballots forward of options who not too long ago gained eligibility, akin to Leyland in 2019 and Mike Scioscia this yr.

White acquired “fewer than three votes” on the 2010 Veterans Committee poll for Executives and Pioneers; no one was elected through that group, although Marvin Miller and Jacob Ruppert subsequently gained entry. Managers and umpires had been thought-about individually that yr, the ultimate one earlier than the Veterans Committee was restructured into the unique trio of Period Committees. White was additionally thought-about twice through the expanded Veterans Committee ballots voted upon by all residing Corridor of Famers (and numerous and varied others), receiving 28.4% in 2003 and 29.3% in ’07; no one was elected through both of these ballots.

That 2010 Veterans Committee was the final time non-players had been thought-about individually from gamers, although even with the latest restructuring, pre-1980 candidates of every kind are lumped collectively. The blending usually satisfies no one, as it might create backlogs of overly certified candidates and make it more durable for different candidates to get a shot. No supervisor has been elected since 2014, when Bobby Cox, Tony La Russa, and Joe Torre had been all unanimously elected, with the 9 different candidates (together with Miller, Steinbrenner, and supervisor Billy Martin) every receiving six or fewer votes; since then, post-integration managers are 0-for-6. Modern executives have had more moderen success, with John Schuerholz and Bud Selig elected through the 2017 At the moment’s Sport poll and Miller through the 2020 Trendy Baseball poll. Hank O’Day was the final umpire elected through the 2013 Pre-Integration poll.

I’ll have extra to say about all of those candidates sooner or later after the World Sequence, however right here’s a short overview of the eight.

Cito Gaston

After an 11-year main league profession (1967–78) that included time within the Braves outfield with Henry Aaron and Dusty Baker (individually, alas) and an All-Star look with the Padres, Gaston turned a hitting coach after which supervisor of the Blue Jays for 2 separate stints (1989–97, 2008–10). In the course of the first one, he led Toronto to 4 division titles and have become the primary Black supervisor to win a World Sequence in 1992, then led the franchise to a repeat in ’93.

Jim Leyland

In a 22-year profession following seven years as a light-hitting catcher within the minors, Leyland managed the Pirates (1986–96), Marlins (1997–98), Rockies (1999), and Tigers (2006–13) to a complete of eight postseason appearances. He gained three division titles with the Barry Bonds-era Pirates and the 1997 World Sequence with the Marlins, and after a six-year retirement following a dismal yr with the Rockies, he got here again to guide the Tigers to 4 playoff appearances, together with pennants in 2006 and ’12. His 1,769 wins as a supervisor rank 18th all-time.

Davey Johnson

Johnson solely managed 14 full seasons and components of three others with the Mets (1984–90), Reds (1993–95), Orioles (1996–97), Dodgers (1999-2000), and Nationals (2011-13) however completed under second in a full season simply as soon as. From amongst his six division titles and one Wild Card berth, he’s greatest recognized for main the Mets to the 1986 World Sequence win and the Nationals to their first playoff berth in 2012. Amongst AL/NL managers whose careers crossed into the twentieth or twenty first century and who managed no less than 1,000 video games, his .562 profitable share ranks tenth.

Lou Piniella

After an 18-year main league profession that spanned from 1964 to ’84 and included World Sequence rings with the 1977 and ’78 Yankees, Piniella spent 21 full seasons and components of two others managing the Yankees (1986–87, ’88), Reds (1990–92), Mariners (1993–2002), Satan Rays (2003–05), and Cubs (2007–10). He led the Reds to a 1990 championship however couldn’t get any of his different groups — together with the 116-win 2001 Mariners — again to the World Sequence regardless of 5 further division titles and a Wild Card look. He’s seventeenth all-time with 1,835 wins.

Ed Montague

Montague spent 35 seasons as an umpire, working completely within the NL (1974, ’76–99) after which in each leagues (2000–10) as soon as they had been mixed into a standard pool. He labored in seven World Sequence and is one in every of simply 4 umpires who served as crew chief for no less than three World Sequence and as dwelling plate umpire for no less than three All-Star Video games. His 4,369 regular-season video games as an umpire rank thirteenth all-time.

Joe West

A polarizing determine who was concerned in quite a few confrontations and controversies with gamers and managers, West spent 24 years as an NL umpire (1976–99) after which one other 20 as a significant league umpire (2002–21), working in six World Sequence. Regardless of lacking two seasons in between these stretches after collaborating in a mass resignation throughout a labor dispute, he set all-time data with 43 seasons and 5,460 video games umpired, breaking marks beforehand held by Invoice Klem. He’s the primary umpire to achieve the poll from a interval the place we are able to monitor his efficiency because of instantaneous replay and Statcast, which can not work in his favor.

Hank Peters

In a profession that spanned over 4 a long time, from 1946 to ’91, Peters helped lay the groundwork for 2 powerhouses: the mid-Nineteen Seventies A’s as an govt with their Kansas Metropolis forerunners, and the mid-Nineties Cleveland squad because the group’s president and common supervisor from ’87 to ’91. Within the latter capability, he drafted Jim Thome and Manny Ramirez, and traded Joe Carter in a blockbuster that introduced again Sandy Alomar Jr. snd Carlos Baerga. His principal declare to fame, nevertheless, was because the GM of the Orioles from 1975 to ’87. Throughout that point, he navigated the daybreak of free company and made key trades that helped the group win no less than 90 video games six instances, highlighted by a pennant in 1979 and a championship in ’83.

Invoice White

After a 13-year taking part in profession (1956–69) that included 5 All-Star appearances and a championship with the Cardinals, White spent 18 years as a broadcaster for the Yankees and for nationwide networks; he was the primary common Black play-by-play announcer for a significant league group. His pioneering continued when he was elected to develop into the Nationwide League president in 1989, making him the primary high-ranking Black govt in any main sport. He served in that publish by means of 1994.

Of the group, I favor Leyland among the many managers, viewing his credentials because the strongest, however wouldn’t be shocked if Piniella builds upon previous help to realize entry. For the entire negativity that’s prone to encompass West’s candidacy so far as the general public goes, I think his longevity might be rewarded with election as nicely.

Supply hyperlink


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here