Tyler Glasnow was 21 years outdated and filled with promise as he sat atop our 2015 Pittsburgh Pirates Prime Prospects record when it was revealed in January of that yr. Our then-lead prospect analyst Kiley McDaniel gave plus grades to each Glasnow’s heater and his hook, opining that the tall right-hander had no. 2 starter potential.
Regardless of an damage historical past that features Tommy John surgical procedure, Glasnow has largely lived as much as expectations. Drafted 152nd total in 2011 out of William S. Hart Excessive College in Santa Clarita, California, he was traded to the Tampa Bay Rays in July 2018 (a deadline deal Pirates followers would like to overlook) and logged a 3.20 ERA and three.10 FIP over 71 begins in his five-plus seasons there. Subsequently swapped to the Los Angeles Dodgers in December 2023, Glasnow has a 3.47 ERA and a 3.28 FIP over 31 begins together with his present membership. He’s top-of-the-rotation high quality when totally match, however he has had bother staying wholesome. Simply this season, he was out from late April till early July with shoulder irritation.
What did Glasnow’s 2015 FanGraphs scouting report seem like? Furthermore, what does he give it some thought all these years later? Wanting to search out out, I shared a few of what McDaniel wrote and requested Glasnow to reply to it.
———
“Glasnow was drafted within the fifth spherical out of highschool in 2011 as a low-profile pure-projection guess with fringy-to-average stuff and a restricted observe file.”
“That’s most likely fairly correct,” Glasnow replied. “I used to be fifth spherical, simply extra projectable, and throwing 89-91 [mph]. I had a good curveball, nevertheless it wasn’t excellent but. My stuff was respectable for highschool, however in comparison with professional ball, probably not. I used to be decrease velo, largely simply two pitches, and I had a really unhealthy changeup.”
“He blew up in 2013, dominating Low-A with a fastball that hit 97 mph. He continued his progress at Excessive-A in 2014, sitting 93-96 mph and hitting 98 mph.”
“Fairly correct,” he agreed. “I used to be rising into myself. A bit little bit of it was mechanical. I was actually lengthy and late, and I simply bought extra on time. I undoubtedly bought somewhat bit stronger. I bought drafted at 17, so it might have been a mix of age and improved mechanics.”
“A plus curveball and enhancing changeup.”
“The curveball has all the time been there,” he mentioned of his top-notch breaker. “The changeup has by no means improved. It was all the time unhealthy, so I simply stopped throwing it. I feel the final time I threw one was most likely 2019 — that was only one or two — nevertheless it was 2017 or 2018 after I stopped, for probably the most half. I messed round with a break up somewhat bit, however I by no means… I didn’t prefer it.”
(Statcast final tracked a changeup from Glasnow in 2023, when it says he threw 5, to go together with 34 in 2021, 45 in 2020, and 32 in 2019. Both approach, he was hardly throwing it throughout these years, and during the last two seasons, he has fully deserted it.)
“Glasnow’s lengthy limbs create some command/supply challenges that he’s already made plenty of progress with.”
“That was when, 2015? Sure. It was higher than it was early, for positive,” mentioned Glasnow, who stands 6-foot-8. “My stroll charge went down yearly. I did nonetheless have tough spots round that time. In 2016 and 2017 it type of sucked once more, after which it bought higher. I feel somewhat little bit of [the command issue] was not being tremendous assured. After which the supply, the repeatability.
“I used to be all the time so hit or miss each begin, and I didn’t have a grip on why I used to be unhealthy sure begins,” he mentioned when requested to elaborate on his insecurity. “I simply didn’t have plenty of management of my physique. I’d say 2015 was a superb yr, so it was wonderful — even when somewhat hit and miss — however 2016 and 2017 within the large leagues it wasn’t so good. I feel that’s when my confidence was at its lowest. I bought traded in 2018, after which it bought higher.”
“His velo was down a tick within the AFL, together with his command and offspeed pitches now fairly the identical, however that appeared to simply be fatigue from an extended season for a thin child nonetheless including bulk to his body.”
“I don’t keep in mind being tremendous fatigued,” he mentioned. “I feel a giant difficulty is that there have been so many occasions within the minor leagues the place I might have a superb month, a nasty month, a superb month. Mechanically, issues would simply type of… it was simply laborious to throw laborious. I don’t even know what I used to be doing. But it surely was inconsistent. The Fall League was simply a type of months the place I sucked. I simply didn’t really feel excellent. Yeah, it wasn’t nice.”
“Has an uncanny skill to command his curveball, one thing I’ve solely seen from José Fernández amongst prospects at this degree.”
“I did nicely in 2014,” he recalled. “I nonetheless had a reasonably excessive stroll charge, however my curveball was good for strikes. I solely threw two pitches, so it was respectable in 2014 for positive. Some days it was horrible, however in plenty of others it was good.”
“There’s no. 2 starter upside, with much less threat every the day.”
“I feel after I was good, it was fairly apparent that I used to be good,” Glasnow mentioned. “Once I was unhealthy, it was fairly apparent that I used to be unhealthy. I assume at the moment it was a good evaluation.”
——
Earlier “Outdated Scouting Reviews Revisited” interviews may be discovered by means of these hyperlinks: Shane Baz, Cody Bellinger, Matthew Boyd, Dylan Stop, Matt Chapman, Erick Fedde, Kyle Freeland, Max Fried, Lucas Giolito, Randal Grichuk, Ian Happ, Jordan Hicks, Jeff Hoffman, Tanner Houck, Matthew Liberatore, Tyler Mahle, Sean Newcomb, Bailey Ober, Matt Olson, Austin Riley, Joe Ryan, Max Scherzer, Marcus Semien.