I got here throughout this on Instagram sooner or later.
A robust a part of me reacts to this by suggesting it comes from somebody who pushes 1-on-1 coaching classes. I don’t know if that’s the case right here or not. My thoughts instant goes there, although.
Sure, I may be fairly cynical at occasions. 🙂
Placing that apart, nonetheless, my response to this meme comes right down to what the speaker actually means. Is it that gamers should practice individually on their very own exterior what they do with their group to essentially develop?
If that’s the proper interpretation, then it poses a pair issues.
First, it minimizes the function group coaching performs in talent growth. Sure, a given particular person is sort of sure to get fewer reps in a group setting than in a person one. Most likely much less suggestions as nicely (although I tackle this in The Excellent Drill). The context of these reps matter, nonetheless. If correctly structured (massive caveat), the team-setting reps will likely be of upper high quality. That’s as a result of they’re much extra consultant than could be particular person reps.
Extra consultant = higher switch to make use of in sport context = fewer reps required for a similar positive factors.
In different phrases extra reps doesn’t essentially imply extra growth.
Second, it assumes that the participant is aware of what they should work on (a serious problem for inexperienced gamers). Additionally that they will get high quality help in these particular person reps. A participant who doesn’t know what they really want to work on, or how to try this in an efficient manner, isn’t prone to get very far. Equally, a participant working with somebody who doesn’t actually know what the participant wants to enhance on, or lacks the teaching skill to do the job nicely, received’t see the type of positive factors they want.
There’s additionally the query of coaching load. Massive distinction on this context between somebody whose group practices as soon as every week and one which has 5 classes every week. A participant who triples their rep depend by including a person session could be very prone to see advantages from doing so, even when they aren’t the highest quality.
I wholeheartedly agree that somebody seeking to maximize their potential should put within the work individually. I’d simply problem the place that work must be finished in quite a lot of instances. For a lot of, the larger positive factors from particular person work come from doing S&C, finding out video, taking with their coaches, and issues like that.
That every one stated, we must always count on gamers to have most concentrate on talent growth when these observe alternatives are put in entrance of them.
The submit Do gamers want particular person coaching? appeared first on Teaching Volleyball.