Charlie Morton has been about to retire for some time now. The lanky curveball specialist first made headlines within the early 2010s; he’d been struggling over his first three main league seasons, so he got here up with a novel, however hilariously easy, answer: Copy what Roy Halladay was doing. It labored for some time, however accidents piled up, and it wasn’t till Morton landed with the Astros in 2017 that he actually, really put it collectively.
Within the first season of a two-year cope with the Astros, Morton set new profession highs in wins, WAR, and strikeouts. He not solely received a championship for the primary time in his profession, he was the successful pitcher in Sport 7 of each the ALCS and the World Sequence, and received the final out of the season within the latter case. He turned 34 5 days after the Astros’ championship parade, and by the next spring he was already musing publicly about hanging up his spikes.
In April 2018, he informed Jake Kaplan of The Athletic that he may retire as soon as his contract expired on the finish of the season. I’ll quote a larger-than-normal chunk of his rationalization, since you don’t often see this type of candor from athletes:
“I miss my household. Household is crucial factor to me. My spouse has been unimaginable with how she’s dealt with the change to changing into somebody that’s mainly a assist system. She had desires of what she needed to do together with her life, and I’m positive it wasn’t shifting to wherever I used to be and revolving her life round what I used to be doing. However that’s precisely what occurred. And we’ve been actually lucky financially with the success I’ve had in my profession. However it’s not like I need to hold enjoying simply to maintain enjoying. As a result of I’m cognizant of her wants and eager to do one thing for herself and likewise our youngsters, who would like to have me at dwelling. My objectives in baseball have just about been fulfilled.”
That was seven years in the past, and Morton remains to be pitching. This isn’t a man who goes alongside to get alongside; Morton has a status not just for being sensible, however for being his personal man, doing issues his method. If he’s nonetheless punching the clock at age 41, he should have a great cause.
I guess Morton would’ve known as it quits years in the past if groups didn’t hold throwing piles of cash at him.
Morton made his first All-Star staff in 2018 and hit free company that winter. To that time, he’d earned about $40 million whole in his profession. However the precise scenario arrived in 2019: The Rays wanted a veteran chief for a promising younger employees that included Blake Snell, Tyler Glasnow, Ryne Stanek, and Brendan McKay, and so they have been keen to pay Morton a franchise-record $30 million contract for 2 years of labor.
Almost double your cash and nonetheless retire at 36? That’s price sticking round for. Morton led the Rays again to the playoffs in 2019 and completed third within the Cy Younger voting. In 2020, he made it again to the World Sequence, however the Rays fell to the Dodgers in six video games. Certainly, this might be a great time to stop.
Then the Braves supplied him $15 million for another season. Morton pitched nicely in 33 begins and the Braves received the World Sequence. One other one-year contract adopted, this one for $20 million, together with a 101-win season. Then a one-year deal for $20 million in 2023 with an an identical staff choice for the season after.
In 2024, the Braves merely squeaked into the playoffs and Morton was solely league common in his 30 begins. OK, now looks like a great time to pack it in and return to the household farm.
Until the Orioles need to provide one other $15 million for one final yr, no, we’re severe this time.
Morton has completed extra after his thirty third birthday than most athletes do in a lifetime. The previous man has legitimately been among the best pitchers in baseball since 2017; he’s thirteenth in that point in WAR, ninth in innings, and fourth in strikeouts. Solely eight different gamers at any place can match or beat Morton’s mixture of two World Sequence rings and 22.0 WAR since 2017, and half of these gamers received no less than one among their championships enjoying alongside Morton.
It’s been seven years since Morton first began to speak about retirement, and even longer for the reason that begin of this put up, so I suppose I’ll lastly get to the purpose: It looks like the top is nigh.
Morton, now 41, has appeared in 9 video games for the Orioles this yr. Baltimore is 0-9 in these video games, and Morton has taken the loss an astonishing seven instances. He’s allowed no less than one run each time he’s taken the mound this yr, and two or extra earned runs eight instances out of 9. Morton is now one among seven twenty first Century pitchers, and the primary since 2013, to be charged with seven or extra losses in his staff’s first 35 video games.
It’s no shock that Morton was demoted to the bullpen after 5 begins, with a ten.89 ERA and a 6.91 FIP. He’s since returned to the rotation for a spot begin on Wednesday, and lowered his ERA to 9.38. Most distressing, Morton doesn’t appear to have an thought what’s gone fallacious.
“It could be method simpler if I used to be throwing 89-91 [mph] and my curve wasn’t spinning and my changeup wasn’t sinking and operating and my cutter wasn’t constant,” Morton informed reporters after his final begin. “It could be method simpler simply to go, ‘You already know what, I don’t have it anymore. I simply don’t have the bodily expertise to do it anymore.’ However the issue is I do.”
It’s true; if Morton is shedding his fastball figuratively, he’s not shedding it actually. His velo is down lower than a 3rd of a mile an hour from final yr, a margin so trivial it could not even register beneath regular circumstances. His curveball, if something, is breaking much more than it did in 2024. His elite breaking ball spin has modified neither in amount nor in course.
However he’s not getting forward of hitters as a lot. He’s not hitting the zone as a lot, and when he does work inside the zone he’s leaving a couple of extra pitches over the center of the plate. When he’s outdoors the strike zone, hitters are shedding; his opponent chase fee has dropped from 30.1% in 2023 to twenty-eight.8% in 2024 to 25.7% in 2025. His changeup, which averaged 85.0 mph final yr, is now coming in 2.3 mph quicker, with an inch and a half much less horizontal run.
I’m with Morton right here; I don’t see an apparent mechanical bump or technical collapse that explains how a league-average pitcher is now to this point under substitute stage he’ll get the bends if he regresses to the imply too shortly. Extra doubtless, it’s a mix of little issues. That’s how time at all times will get us.
I way back made my peace with being older than most ballplayers, adjusted my interview type to mirror the truth that most people I’m speaking to weren’t alive for the canceled World Sequence of 1994 and don’t bear in mind Tony Gwynn or Greg Maddux. On the draft mix, I’ve began operating into gamers who have been born after I graduated highschool. Folks roughly my age are beginning to filter into the ranks of GMs and POBOs. When you’re sufficiently old to recollect first-wave emo, you’re in all probability sporting 1 / 4 zip to work, not spikes and mitt.
However I’ve at all times felt a small measure of consolation realizing that there are nonetheless ballplayers who’re actually older than me. I don’t like that that is comforting; it isn’t solely an arrogance, it’s a ineffective vainness, and one shared by each baseball fan whose knees begin to creak.
These ranks are scaling down. I turned 38 the day earlier than Opening Day, and to this point this yr, solely 15 gamers my age or older have appeared in a significant league recreation. And it hasn’t gone nicely, for essentially the most half. Max Scherzer’s gotten harm; Adam Ottavino, Yuli Gurriel, and Carlos Carrasco have already been DFA’d or launched. Jesse Chavez has gotten DFA’d or launched about 15 instances already, and can in all probability get signed and reduce twice extra by the Braves earlier than this piece runs.
Right here’s one factor I do not forget that youthful massive leaguers in all probability don’t: A big group of gamers persevering with to carry out successfully within the majors into their 40s.
You possibly can see it within the graph right here. Six 40-and-over guys within the majors to this point this yr really represents a bumper crop within the context of the 2020s, however they’re far fewer in quantity and in high quality than they have been 20 years in the past.
What’s modified? Properly, you’ll be able to see it in Morton’s ongoing retirement calculus. Salaries have exploded, which suggests gamers like Morton don’t should hold grinding if all they’ll get is a minor league contract and a non-roster invite. It was solely a month in the past that Lance Lynn, a pitcher in a scenario similar to Morton’s, defined that he had provides to pitch in an enormous league rotation for tens of millions of {dollars}, however the extra he thought of it, the extra it simply wasn’t well worth the bother anymore.
Entrance places of work’ understanding of the ageing curve has advanced as nicely; we not depend on Nelson Cruzes to maintain producing when it’s clear that 21-year-olds can hack it within the majors. Particularly since you may discover that the height of that graph, and the decline to the trough we’re in now, traces up with the stigmatization of performance-enhancing medicine. Gone are the times when gamers can rip HGH with impunity and play till they’re 45 with out lacking a beat.
Morton won’t know why he can’t get outs anymore, nevertheless it occurs to everybody. He’s already been an outlier, an iconoclast, a holdout from a bygone age in additional methods than one. Time is the one undefeated opponent; Morton outran it longer than most, however he was by no means going to remain forward of the culling perpetually.
var SERVER_DATA = Object.assign(SERVER_DATA || {});